Apr 27, 2018
Executives
Karen Keyes - Senior Vice President, IR David Johnston - Group Chief Executive Mark Grafton - Chief Financial Officer Steve Leonard - Vice President and Chief Accounting Officer
Analysts
Stephanie Price - CIBC World Markets Tim Casey - BMO Capital Markets Brian Morrison - TD Securities Drew McReynolds - RBC Capital Markets Kevin Kovacs - GSO Capital Partners
Operator
Good morning. My name is Marcella and I will be your conference operator today.
At this time, I’d like to welcome everyone to the Aimia Inc. First Quarter Results Conference Call.
All lines have been placed on mute to prevent background noise. After the speakers’ remarks, there will be a question-and-answer session.
[Operator Instructions] Thank you. Ms.
Karen Keyes, Head of Investor Relations, you may begin your conference.
Karen Keyes
Thank you very much, Marcella. Good morning to all of you attending on the phone and the webcast this morning.
With me on the call today are David Johnston, our Chief Executive; Mark Crafton, Chief Financial Officer; and Steve Leonard, Vice President and Chief Accounting Officer. Before we get underway, I would like to remind everyone to review our forward-looking statements and the cautions and risk factors pertaining to the statements.
For those of you following along on the webcast, you should see these on the screen in front of you now. For those of you accessing the presentation which can be downloaded on the website, these can be found on Page 2.
I’d also like to point out the presentation refers to a number of non-GAAP metrics to help you better understand the results of the business. The definitions of these and reconciliation to their most comparable GAAP metric can be found on Pages Three and Four.
We have also included a full income statement on Page Five and a reconciliation of our return on invested capital metric on Page six. Finally, our presentation today will focus on consolidated results with variances excluding other businesses sold in 2017 as set out in Slide Seven.
These results are presented on an IFRS basis with this quarter being the first to incorporate IFRS 15, the revenue accounting standard that came into effect for issuers beginning this quarter. Mark will speak to this in more detail later.
We’ll aim to wrap up remarks in about 20 minutes to leave time for your questions. And with that, I’ll hand over to David.
David Johnston
Thanks, Karen, and good morning, everyone. This time last year we set out three key priorities for the business.
Firstly, progressing our strategic and commercial partnerships discussions to design a broader and more differentiated Aeroplan program, secondly, ongoing business simplification and acceleration of cost savings, and finally preserving strong cash and liquidity. Those priorities have been the bases of the decisions that we’ve made since and we continued to execute well against them.
We’ve made progress this quarter with the addition of new retailers and partner contract extensions at Aeroplan. This further simplification of the business and the debt and liability reductions that we announced, alongside the Nectar transaction in February.
We were already on a path to simplify the business and cut cost last year. So we knew that the potential to make immediate progress on the cost and balance sheet was greatest.
We also know the clarity on the future of the Aeroplan business is critical for our members, partners and shareholders. Aeroplan is a powerful asset based on a strong brand and engaged in long-term member base that’s been with us for years and its co-branded card portfolio that gives us a place in the wallets of millions of Canadians representing more than 9% of Canadian credit card purchase volume.
The beginning of a new Aeroplan messaging and the member campaign we’re launching today will provide more clarity around the direction we are pursuing and provide context around some of the recent announcements such as the addition of Amazon. It’s also the base on which we are exploring opportunities with our potential and existing partners.
Our Promise campaign articulates the brand commitments we are making to members to help them better understand the direction this program is taking and what it will mean for them starting in 2020. In the near-term, members will start to see a larger pool of accommodations, destination activities and vacation packages.
Finally, let me turn to the highlights of the quarter and a little more detail on our progress on cost reduction before handing you over to Mark. We said we delivered one quarter at a time and our Q1 financials were solid.
Gross billings were stable at around $358 million reflecting a solid performance at Aeroplan. Margin was up from 11% in the same quarter last year to 17.3%.
And finally, we saw a change in the quarterly cash profile of the business post-connect to disposals, we reported positive first quarter free cash flow with $25 million of cash in the quarter, which meant that we continue to have over $0.5 billion of cash and investments in bonds on the balance sheets in the end of March. Getting to the right cost base, going into 2020, it’s clearly key.
$17 million reduction in operating expense drove margin improvement of around 620 basis points in the quarter with margin in the coalitions division up almost 700 BPS. Cost savings were achieved by continuing to rationalize our real estate footprint further consolidating our footprint in Toronto, Montreal and London and subletting some of the space freed up previously in Vancouver and Montreal.
This isn’t just about getting cost out but a rethink around how we organize corporate overheads, real estate and IT into a more streamlined business. This has allowed our teams to continue to manage effectively despite another 350 people exiting the business in the quarter through a combination of disposals and operational efficiency.
We are continuing to target $70 million of cost savings with around half of that’s expected this year. So let me now hand over to Mark to take you through more detail on the business performance in the quarter and how it’s continued to strengthen the balance sheet.
Mark Grafton
Thanks, David, and good morning, to everyone. Before I take you through the numbers, let me first touch on the implementation of IFRS 15.
As Karen mentioned, Q1 is the first quarter we are reporting under IFRS 15 and we will be doing so going forward. Our 2017 comparatives are being restated to enable a simple year-on-year comparison.
We’ve also provided Q1 2018 numbers on a pre-IFRS 15 basis to help you see like-for-like. Importantly, for the almost 80% of gross billings and revenue that is Aeroplan, there is no impact.
We have however has to restate 2017 gross billings and revenue in our Air Miles Middle East and reward fulfillment activities to recognize billings and revenue on a net basis. With approximately $96 million impacting to full year 2017 gross billings, and around $131 million impact to full year revenues, of which $20 million and $30 million related to Q1.
Importantly, there was no impact to adjusted EBITDA or free cash flows. In Q1, we continued to see some of the trends David spoke to you about last quarter.
In summary, gross billings were broadly stable as members continued to accumulate. We saw redemption growth that was manageable and broadly in line with our expectations.
And importantly, we saw improvements to member satisfaction driven impart by enhancements we made to the online shopping experience for our members. We also continued to evolve our business model and drove significant cost improvements.
So let me take you through some of these one at a time starting with gross billings. Our financial cost portfolio delivered this solid performance with gross billings up slightly over the last year.
Amex billings grew again this quarter with strong conversion campaigns for the second quarter in a row. Bank card acquisition campaigns, particularly at TD were first half weighted in 2017 with the banks in market with bonus miles offers this time last year.
These lower promotional miles was a major contributor to the decline in accumulation this quarter. And although lower card acquisitions in the second half of the year have resulted in a lower active base this quarter, spend per card was up.
Card attrition on our Aeroplan co-brand cards remains broadly consistent with pre-announcement levels and Aeroplan co-brand cards remain among the first in wallet for many Canadians. Outside of financial costs, gross billings were down slightly, largely due to lower billings from Air Canada, as members shifted to more Tango fares.
Airlines continued to operate in a dynamic market and to seek to differentiate fares. Those fares could come at lower levels of margin accumulation as we saw recently with Air Canada.
While we still expect increased capacity at Air Canada was a growth driver, it’s not clear whether new fare class mix could dampen the growth and mileage issuance we have previously expected. The retail space is interesting one as we transform Aeroplan.
In the quarter, increased bonusing and marketing drove growth with average budget and home hardware. In the end of the quarter, we’ve also got a lot of attention with few changes to our retail mix with the Esso and Amazon announcements.
While Esso and Amazon are not materially in the overall revenue mix, the shift you will see in our retail relationships will be important in driving member engagements with a broader range of retailers through which you can earn miles. The positive reaction to the Amazon relationship which formally launched this week gives us confidence in the research we have done and tells us this kind of expanded offering is something that our members will value.
I know many of you will be very focused on the redemption path that we saw in the quarter and the end of our relationship with Esso is also relevant here. On the back of our Esso announcement in March, we saw some increase in non-air gift cards.
The overall redemption expense increase of $20 million in the quarter, 9% higher than last year was within our range of expectations. We continue to monitor redemption levels with redemptions averaging up to the second quarter at high single-digit increases.
Remember though that the Air Canada non-renewal announcement occurred in May. So it was not a factor members in the first quarter of last year.
Taking a slightly longer view, redemptions are 7% over the trailing 12 months period to the end of March. Our guidance assumes redemption growth levels to slow through the back half of the year as we cycle the post-May redemptions increase and air capacity grows.
In the quarter, changes in airline capacity were also a contributor to redemption growth. Similar to what we saw in Q4, members took more attractive redemptions based on lower prices and more seats available.
We also saw higher availability in capacity with a few partnered airlines in the quarter and that converted into high redemptions on trans-border and international flights. The stable accumulations and higher redemptions resulted in higher burn out and a 109% compared to last year at 97%.
With unit cost broadly aligned with last year reflecting mixed changes in the quarter, the increase in redemption expense mirror the increase in miles redeemed in the quarter. So let me now talk you through the overview of where that landed it in the quarter on a continuing operations basis.
Setting aside the $37 million decline in gross billings as a result of disposals, gross billings were down around $5 million with a $6 million decline in the Insights and Loyalty Solutions business offset by $1 million increase in coalitions. The decrease in the Insights and Loyalty Solutions business largely stems from the end of our service contracts in April of 2017 and challenging market conditions in the Middle East.
Looking at the bridge from gross billings to free cash flows allows you to clearly see the impact of key items in the quarter with cost of rewards largely reflecting the $20 million increased redemption expense in Aeroplan we mentioned earlier. Total redemption expense in the quarter was $347 million with the vast majority in Aeroplan.
The timing of interest payments on our bonds and revolver which occur in May and November meant that no interest was paid in the quarter nor that we have tax payments in the quarter. Capital expenditure was an unusually low item in the quarter with the sale of capital equipment to an IT supplier for $3 million, which was set against the $4 million of business as usual spend.
And finally, working capital included a rent prepayment relating to the space our business continues to occupy in London with the lease of the property having transferred to Sainsbury’s as part of the Nectar transaction. Restructuring cash in the quarter was approximately $5 million.
Q1 was a positive cash flow quarter. The $25 million of free cash flow from continuing operations was in line with 2017.
As you think about quarterly phasing, it is worth noting that Aeroplan billings and hence cash flows are typically stronger in the second half of the year. However Q1 did benefit from the absence of any tax or interest payments, which we expect to see through the balance of the year.
All things considered, free cash flow for Q1 was within our range of expected outcome. Prior to the disposal of Nectar, Q1 was typically a negative cash flow quarter as the bill to seasonally significant redemptions within the Nectar program was settled in January.
With the sale of the Nectar business, Aimia’s cash flow profile is now much more linked to the cash generation profile of Aeroplan. Let me come back to OpEx and CapEx for a moment.
OpEx in the quarter was down 16% to $92 million. While the bulk of that related to our ongoing cost reduction exercise, I would note that lower compensation costs, partly related to a bonus accrual reversal and the timing of advertising and marketing spends which will occur later this year were also contributors to lower spend in the quarter.
In total, these two items were around $4 million versus the prior year. Turning now to CapEx.
CapEx came down significantly in 2017. As we look across 2018, we continue to expect capital expenditure in the range of $30 million to $35 million.
Our CapEx this year, as well as over the last two years was already partly devoted to the travel platform which underpins our new car rental and hotel offerings and we continue to evaluate how we can incorporate the use of new technologies and analytics developments as we evolve Aeroplan further. As you look at the completion accounting around the Nectar transaction, you will see two numbers that offset each other.
With a significant working capital inflow during January resulting in free cash flow generation of $16 million are higher than what we expected through normal trading. This results in a payment being due under the working capital mechanic, but net-net it is within our expectation.
We expect to finalize the completion accounts process during Q2. Our cash and bond investments on the balance sheet at the end of the quarter totaled $560 million.
In addition to the $20 million to be used to settle the completion accounts, 50% of Q1 free cash flow or around $20 million will be used to partially pay down our revolver in line with a recent amendment to our credit agreement. This will reduce the draw down on the facility to $88 million and total debt to around $340 million including the letter of credit we have written against the facility.
Looking at the balance sheet, I would also call out a few things. Further to its IPO in February, the Cardlytics business has broadly traded in a range of US$13 to US$19 a share.
We have marked the investments in market at the end of the current quarter. Our investment in PLM Premier continue to generate a solid return with a distribution of $4.4 million.
The business continues to perform well, adding to its member base and delivering a margin of 33.5%. Like for the similar businesses, its profitability impart reflects the program’s maturity and higher breakage.
In the quarter, PLM reported gross billings of 30% to $73 million. You will also note the removal of the $5 million contingent consideration in assets relating to the disposal of the Air Miles Canada Rogue business.
The additional consideration was contingent on the length of any Air Miles contract renewal with BMO and the ongoing level of royalty income. The length of the BMO contract renewal was shortened from five years to three, and many of you may have seen diversified royalty statements that at current runrates, the royalty stream will not be high enough to trigger the payment.
Finally, let me turn to guidance for 2018, which we are reaffirming today and which was not impacted by the implementations of IFRS 15. And with that, let me hand you over to David to wrap up.
David Johnston
All right, thanks, Mark. So before we go to questions, let me just summarize with a few takeaways.
First quarter 2018 demonstrated continued stability with Aeroplan in particular delivering solid accumulations and ongoing operational progress. Overall execution against cost savings and simplification of the business has driven significant margin improvement and robust cash flows.
Balance sheet remains strong with around $0.5 billion at the end of the quarter. And finally we are delighted to start sharing our new campaign for Aeroplan.
The launch of the Promise campaign builds on the assets and capabilities already in place, but will start to transform our interactions with members well before 2020 with Aeroplan expanding the kind of extraordinary travel experiences Canadian have been enjoying for the last 30 years. So now, let’s go to questions.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from the line of Stephanie Price from CIBC. Your line is open.
Stephanie Price
Good morning.
David Johnston
Good morning.
Stephanie Price
You mentioned that redemptions are in line with your expectations this quarter. Can you walk through how you are thinking about redemptions for the remainder of the year?
I think you mentioned that you are expecting them to kind of improve in the second half of the year.
Mark Grafton
Yes, let me take that one. Good morning, Stephanie.
I think, if you think about, in Q1 where it was pre – pre the Air Canada announcement, in Q2 the announcement came in May and as you’ve got pretty much half of the quarter pre and half of the quarter post. So we will expect higher redemptions again in Q2.
You see as we sort of illustrated on Slide 23. I mean, once we get past the May announcement point, then we do expect growth rates to moderate through the second half of the year.
Stephanie Price
Okay. And then gross billings, it looks like you are down about 2% year-over-year, can you talk a bit more about what you are seeing there?
I think you mentioned you have seen a few other things?
Mark Grafton
Yes, I mean, I think from a gross billings perspective, I mean, I think the main number for me as you know on sort of – from sort of coalitions perspective, gross billings are up $1 million year-over-year. Accumulation, yes, outside of premier miles is pretty much flat.
So I view that as a stable quarter around coalitions gross billings.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Tim Casey from BMO. Your line is open.
Tim Casey
Yes, could you talk a little bit about the management changes you have announced today, David? I mean, what’s the Board dynamic in terms of your departure?
And what is the plan going forward for the leadership of the company? Thank you.
David Johnston
Sure. Look, I think the timing was appropriate.
Obviously, I’ve had a number of discussions with the Board and as Aimia sort of business and geographic footprint shrinks, then I think it was a logical timing for me and as you hear today, you started to see some new news on Aeroplan and you will be seeing more and I think, now it is the right time for new leadership to step in and take Aeroplan on that next part of its journey. And the Board has a process already in place.
So I am confident you don’t hear more news on that pretty quickly.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Brian Morrison from TD Securities. Your line is open.
Brian Morrison
Good morning. Mark, a quick question on the free cash flow in the quarter.
Is it apples-to-oranges with the Nectar transaction from last year? So I am wondering if you can provide color on the coalition free cash flow this year versus last.
I believe it’s $25 million in Q1 2018. Where would have that have landed last year and presumably the positive inputs would have been lower SG&A and the negative would have been higher redemptions, correct?
Mark Grafton
Yes, I mean, if we look at the businesses that we’ve got on a continuing basis, then the $25 million is up 7% year-over-year. We’ve got a slide in the deck, Slide 25 that sort of walks you through that for the continuing businesses as a whole and I sort of talked some of those points in the script.
So, redemption cost of operating expenditure is a dime within those businesses that we retain. The $25 million that we are focused on that excludes the Nectar business altogether.
So the $22 million to $25 million is completed like-for-like.
Brian Morrison
Okay, so it’s essentially flat.
Mark Grafton
Well, it’s, yes.
Brian Morrison
Okay, $25 million to $23 million. So, second question, and this is for David.
In your commitments, it’s point number two, is the power to reach your travel plan faster, I guess in my mind, that means you accumulate miles at an accelerated pace or your redemptions for reward require less miles which seems a little bit challenge in absent to CPSA and Classic rewards. So, can you just talk about achieving travel plans faster than other programs which you comment or your current offering that presumably Air Canada will be able to offer to relative to your offer to you such time.
David Johnston
Yes, earnings miles factor is one of the core benefits of a broad coalition program, because you are earning across everywhere you spend and clearly we want to earn – we want to add more earned partners and you are seeing that with the addition of Amazon this quarter and I think you’ll see more. So, for me, faster is really about the – at the level of burn and the breadth of the places that you are able to deliver burn.
But clearly, we are very mindful of the fact that come 2020, we’ve also – we will also deliver travel pricing that is competitive in the marketplace.
Brian Morrison
So, are there major verticals to accumulate that you feel that you are not in right now?
David Johnston
Yes, look, there is always areas we can add. You’ve seen some excitement with the Amazon announcement and I think we can do more specifically online as an example.
But there is other areas we can get into as well. But online is a real focus for us at the moment.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Drew McReynolds from RBC. Your line is open.
Drew McReynolds
Thanks, very much good morning. Couple questions.
On the partnership front for Aimia or on Aeroplan, David, can you just talk to just how engage TD and CIBC are just with promotions kind of in markets and what their response today is on the program moving forward? And then, can you just give us an update on the American Express renewal?
And I have one other. Thank you.
David Johnston
Great, sure. So that we are very engaged with all of our partners, and in particular our banking partners, both on the current operation of the program and on the future direction of the program.
So, we’re working well with them on to 2018, 2019 plans, as well as the shape of the program and post 2020 clearly partners , as with shareholders, as with members would like as much clarity as possible, that exactly what post 2020 looks like and we are working to get to that point. But now I would say, we are working well.
American Express, it’s the same answer given before to be on a set contract – the current contract comes to an end at the end of 2018 and we’ll give you a further update on it before the end of 2018.
Drew McReynolds
Okay. And one last one from me on the PLM stake, clearly you announced that is growing quite nicely.
Can you just give us an update on the appetite for crystallizing that stake? Has there been any progress central to last quarter to along those lines?
David Johnston
You said PLM, just to check, yes.
Drew McReynolds
That’s correct, David, yes.
David Johnston
Yes. No change to what I’d have said in previous quarters.
So, you could look at that business in a couple of ways. It’s clearly very similar and therefore very core to Aeroplan and it’s a business we understand well.
There is a good management team there as you can see delivering very strong operational performance which means we benefit from an attractive dividend. So, as an asset to hold, it’s clearly strategically logical and financially attractive.
On the other hand, it’s clearly also asset that has value in the marketplace and the Board will continue to consider those alternatives. But no real change to what we’ve talked about previously
Operator
[Operator Instructions] Your next question comes from the line of Kevin Kovacs from GSO. Your line is open.
Kevin Kovacs
Hey guys. Good morning.
Similar to the last question, would you be able to give us an update on the Air Asia loyalty program you invested in? I am just curious to know, what the update there is over the last few years.
How it’s been trending? What you think of it overall?
Really anything you can give us.
David Johnston
Yes, sure, so, the Air Asia program called big loyalty, it operates across the Air Asia network, I don’t know how much you know about Air Asia, but it’s a low cost carrier across Asia and Australasia and thus you have a long haul lag as well. It’s a slightly different model, because loyalty in a frequent – sorry – in a low cost carrier obviously some of the economic dynamics in the business model are different.
But, it remains a very interesting business. There is fantastic growth opportunity from a macro upside in the region.
But it’s also – it’s an asset that we continue to work with the other partners quite closely and continue to sort of evaluate how it makes sense for us for the long-term.
Kevin Kovacs
Okay. And then, would you just be able to give us an update on what you are thinking to do with the capital structure at this point?
I mean, is this something where you are just – I mean, are you in the Board, just planning to sit on cash until maturities come up and pay them off? Do you – are you thinking about addressing that sooner, the potential refinancing?
David Johnston
Yes, Mark, do you want to? Mark will speak to that.
Mark Grafton
Yes, sure, I mean, clearly we are looking at the bonds that are coming up for maturity in May 2019. I think the important thing for us is to make sure that we have options around that to clearly repaying them using cash we have on the balance sheet and cash that we will generate between now and then is one option.
We would also look, explore refinancing options. So, keeping – we have a number of paths that we could look at.
Operator
[Operator Instructions] There are no further questions. I turn the call over to David Johnston for closing remarks.
David Johnston
Okay, thank you and thanks everyone for taking the time today and you may recall, but I stepped in as CEO on the day of the Air Canada announcement last year. My brief was to stabilize the business to set a clear direction and then take a series of tough strategic and operational decisions in order to deliver performance while reshaping the company.
As Aimia reshapes itself with a tighter business and geographic footprint, it is the right time for me to move on to further my career elsewhere and for new leadership to step in. I am proud of the results that we’ve delivered over the past year despite clearly significant challenges and I’d like to thank all of our employees for their continued support.
Thanks everyone.
Operator
This concludes today’s conference call. You may now disconnect.