Feb 9, 2016
Executives
Gavin A. Bell - Vice President, Investor Relations William R.
Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer Andrew S.
Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Analysts
Kathryn Lynn Huberty - Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC Daniel R.
Perlin - RBC Capital Markets LLC Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC Matt J. Summerville - Alembic Global Advisors LLC Meghna Ladha - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP Gil B.
Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc. Richard Faulkner - Oppenheimer & Co., Inc.
(Broker)
Operator
Good day, and welcome to the NCR Corporation Fourth Quarter Fiscal Year 2015 Earnings Conference Call. Today's conference is being recorded.
At this time, I'd like to turn the conference over to Mr. Gavin Bell, Vice President of Investor Relations.
Please go ahead, sir.
Gavin A. Bell - Vice President, Investor Relations
Good afternoon and thank you for joining our fourth quarter 2015 earnings call. Joining me on the call today and offering opening remarks are Bill Nuti, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Bob Fishman, Chief Financial Officer.
Additionally, available on the call today for Q&A are Andy Heyman, Senior Vice President and President, Financial Services; Michael Bayer, Senior Vice President and President, Retail Solutions; and Paul Langenbahn, Senior Vice President and President of Hospitality. Our presentations and discussions today include forecasts and statements that are considered forward-looking statements as defined in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995.
While these statements reflect our current outlook, expectations, and beliefs, they are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to vary materially. These risks and uncertainties are described in our earnings release and our periodic filings with the SEC, including our annual report to stockholders.
On today's call, we will be referring to presentation materials posted on our website. We will also be discussing certain non-GAAP financial information such as free cash flow and results excluding the impact of pension and other items.
Reconciliation of these non-GAAP financial measures to the most directly comparable GAAP measures, and other information concerning such measures are included in the presentation materials and in our earnings release. These are also available on the Investor Relations section of NCR's website.
A replay of the call will be available later today on our website, ncr.com. With that, I'd like to turn the call over to Bill Nuti.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Thanks, Gavin. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us today.
Before we get into Q4 and full year results, I wanted to provide a brief retrospective on 2015. First let me say that 2015 turned out to be far more challenging than we initially expected, as a result of slower growing China and Russia markets, significantly increased foreign exchange headwinds, which negatively impacted 2015 revenue by $415 million, profit by $72 million, and EPS by $0.27, a third of which was not included in our initial full year guidance, not to mention, the impact significantly weaker local currencies have on the cost of our products in several strong NCR markets around the world.
Just to put that in perspective, in 2015 the Canadian dollar dropped by 16%, Australian dollar by 10%, Brazilian real by 30%, and the euro by 10%. Additionally, as the year we're on with basically the unexpected macro challenge of lower oil prices and destabilization in many of our stronger oil sensitive countries, geopolitical stabs (03:24) lower global GDP growth than expected, and volatile capital markets in the back half of the year.
On top of all that we were immersed and all encompassing strategic review process that took the better part of a year to complete and successfully culminated within $820 million investment in NCR by Blackstone, coupled with a $1 billion share buyback. With that as a backdrop, I was particularly impressed with NCR's 2015 results.
I want to thank my team for their hard work throughout the year. The NCR team did what they said they were going to do with regard to our key metrics of revenue growth, operating income, EPS and free cash flow, the latter of which as you know, is an investor area of focus and significantly exceeded our initial guidance.
I'm proud of the NCR team. I'm also confident that the diversity of our business and strategic focus on omni-channel solutions were two key reasons for our success.
Through organic and inorganic investments, we have positioned NCR as a clear market and thought leader in the rapidly growing omni-channel market, and we experienced solid software growth. As a result, our omni-channel leadership, coupled with the diversity of our markets, geographies and revenue streams have become important strengths and provide NCR with an ability to produce solid results in a state of unusual headwind.
Now, I'll turn the call over to Bob to provide perspective on Q4 and full year results. Bob?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Thank you, Bill. Slide number four shows our financial highlights for Q4.
Revenue was down 5% on an as reported basis due to continued negative currency headwind. On a constant currency basis, Q4 revenues were flat.
Revenue came in line with our guidance that we provided back in October after adjusting for additional unfavorable FX in the quarter. Recurring revenue increased 6% constant currency and was 41% of total revenue.
Looking at margins, we were pleased with our operational gross margin being up 70 basis points constant currency in the quarter due to a higher mix of software-related revenue. In the bottom left box, Q4 NPOI was up 14% constant currency, and non-GAAP EPS was up 13% constant currency, both strong numbers.
Free cash flow was very solid in the quarter and reflected our improved linearity throughout 2015. Moving to the next slide, which shows our financial highlights for the full year; revenue was down 3% on a reported basis in 2015, but up 3% constant currency.
Constant currency revenue growth was driven mostly by our Retail Solutions and Hospitality segment through further expansion of our software and cloud revenue. Recurring revenue reached 43% of total revenue, compared to 41% at the end of 2014.
Increasing our recurring revenue is a key area of focus at NCR, and the team did a solid job against that goal this year. Operational gross margin was 29.3% in 2015, down 20 basis points for the year.
Although the mix of software-related revenue improved in the year, it did not offset more hardware margin rate. NPOI was up 10% constant currency, and non-GAAP EPS was up 11% constant currency for the year, both very good numbers.
And lastly, free cash flow was $409 million in 2015, up $96 million from the prior year. We made great progress executing against our free cash flow goal, and exceeded our initial full-year free cash flow guidance of $325 million to $375 million.
This has been an ongoing priority for NCR, and I'm pleased with what we've accomplished in 2015. Turning now to slide number six, you'll see our Q4 and full year 2015 software-related revenue.
In Q4, on a constant currency basis, software-related revenue was down 1% and cloud revenue increased 5%. For the full year on a constant currency basis, software-related revenue increased 4% and cloud revenue increased 10%, including strong growth in our Hospitality business.
I'm on slide seven now, which covers our Q4 and full year operational results in a little more detail. We experienced unfavorable foreign currency fluctuations during the fourth quarter with impacts of approximately $90 million in revenue, $21 million in NPOI, and $0.07 in non-GAAP EPS.
On a constant currency basis, fourth quarter revenue was flat, NPOI was higher by 14%, and non-GAAP EPS was higher by 13%. For the full year, foreign currency headwinds were $415 million in revenue, $72 million in NPOI and $0.27 in non-GAAP EPS.
On a constant currency basis, revenue grew 3%, NPOI was up 10%, and non-GAAP EPS grew 11% for the year, all very good numbers, while we continued with our transformation. The next slide shows our fourth quarter and full year GAAP result.
The reconciling items between these GAAP result and operational results are included in the supplementary non-GAAP information slide. As noted on the supplementary slide, reconciling items include amortization of acquired intangibles, acquisition related costs, restructuring related charges and pension expense.
In Q4 2015, pension expense included a $29 million mark-to-market charge compared to $150 million in Q4 2014. Additional reconciling items in the fourth quarter of 2015 are $20 million reserve related to a subcontracting arrangement in Middle East, Africa in the Emerging Industries, and a $34 million non-cash charge relating to the pending divestiture of the IPS business.
We made the decision in Q4 to sell the IPS business and focus our efforts on NCR's core. The Q4 charge reflects IPS being classified as held for sale on our balance sheet and valuing it as fair value.
The decrease in full year GAAP EPS was primarily due to a $427 million non-cash settlement of a pension plan in the UK in the second quarter of 2015. Slide nine shows the revenue by segment.
As you can see, FX had a significant impact in the quarter and the year. On a constant currency basis, Financial Services was down 5% for the quarter, and up 1% for the year.
Retail Solutions was up 4% for the quarter and up 5% for the year. And Hospitality was up 12% for the quarter and up 7% for the year.
Slide 10 is a very important page. It shows that we delivered operating margin expansion in all of our businesses in 2015.
In Financial, we grew full year operating margins by 40 basis points primarily as a result of growing software-related revenue by 5% constant currency, and significantly increasing our high value solutions. Retail Solutions grew operating income by 10% constant currency after a challenging year in 2014.
Higher cloud revenue and good expense management helped the retail business. Hospitality had a terrific year.
Operating margins were up 300 basis points, and operating income grew by 26%. This significant improvement was driven by software-related revenues growing by 17% constant currency.
So again tremendous balance across our businesses in 2015. Improving the mix to higher software-related revenues and strong cost management is the key to driving operating margin dollar growth.
I'll cover Q4 segment result in more detail on the next few slides. On slide 11, you'll see our Financial Services update.
On a constant currency basis, revenues were down 5%. Excluding Brazil, Russia, India and China, revenue was up 1% on a constant currency basis.
Operating margin was up 160 basis points at 18%. This improvement was due to a favorable mix of revenue and expense management.
We remained focused on driving operating margin expansion through our transformation initiatives, improved mix and software growth despite revenue headwinds. Current economic conditions are putting pressure on ATM sales, including the attached software, which is impacting near-term profitability.
Our high value solutions, including branch transformation, cloud and enterprise software improved in the year, driving full year software-related revenue up 5% on a constant currency basis. In addition, we are encouraged by the positive trends in a number of key businesses, including community banks and cloud-delivered digital banking application.
The next slide shows our Retail Solutions' Q4 results. Revenue was up 4% on a constant currency basis due to improvements in the Americas and Europe.
Operating margin was 10.4%, an increase of 150 basis points. Retail operating income increased from the prior year due to higher revenue and expense management.
Q4 software-related revenue was down 10% on a constant currency basis, due to some larger customer rollouts in the prior year. The retail market continues to show improved fundamentals, and our Retail ONE omni-commerce platform is gaining traction in the market after a successful NRF Trade Show.
Additionally, we are recognized for our global leadership position in Point of Service, and were named number one in Global Self-Service Checkouts for the 14th consecutive year according to RBR. Turning to the next slide.
Hospitality revenues were up 12% on a constant currency basis, driven by improvements in the higher margin revenue streams, including cloud and professional services. Operating margin performance was 21.2%, up 430 basis points due to this higher software-related revenue, including cloud and professional services revenue.
We are driving improved results through sales transformation and increased software revenue. Our strong cloud revenue growth is driven by omni-channel applications with cloud application sites up 17%.
We are making traction in international markets, and our SMB market strategy is generating strong results. The full year constant currency software-related revenue was up 17% and cloud revenue was up 24%.
Next, looking at our Emerging Industries business on slide number 14, revenues were up 6% on a constant currency basis, driven by our Telecom & Technology business. Operating income was roughly flat in dollar terms, but we continue to invest in NCR Silver, our cloud-delivered mobile point-of-sale solution for Small Business.
On slide 15, on a constant currency basis, software-related revenue was down 1% for the quarter, but up 4% for the full year. Hardware revenue was down 6% for the quarter, up 2% for the full year, and other services were up 8% for the quarter and 5% for the full year.
Cloud revenue growth was significant, up 10% for the full year on a constant currency basis. On slide 16, you can see free cash flow for the quarter and full year.
Full year free cash flow of $409 million exceeded our expectation and represented 85% of non-GAAP net income, a significant improvement in conversion rate versus prior years. Slide number 17 shows our net debt-to-EBITDA metric where we closed the year a little better than expected, with a net debt leverage ratio of 2.8 times.
Slide 18 includes our full year 2016 guidance. In 2016, we are providing guidance for revenue, earnings per share and free cash flow.
We are now including ongoing pension-related expense in our non-GAAP EPS guidance. Through the actions we have taken related to our pension plans over the last couple of years, we have reduced the volatility of ongoing pension expense and will now include it on a go-forward basis.
Ongoing pension expense includes service cost, interest cost and the expected return on planned assets, but excludes the Q4 mark-to-market adjustment. The top section of the chart shows our revenue, EPS and free cash flow guidance for 2016.
Our revenue guidance is $6.1 billion to $6.2 billion, our non-GAAP EPS guidance is $2.72 to $2.82, and our free cash flow guidance is $425 million to $475 million. In 2016, we will be divesting our IPS business and including ongoing pension-related expense.
For the IPS divestiture, we have assumed the closing at the end of the first quarter. In addition, we are expecting incremental foreign currency headwinds of $135 million versus 2015, with an EPS impact of $0.10.
These three items create an apples-to-oranges comparison to our 2015 reported result. In order to show the operational growth year-on-year, we have included the reconciliation at the bottom of the chart.
As you can see, the constant currency revenue growth on the same basis as 2015 is 3% to 4%, and the non-GAAP EPS growth is a solid 4% to 8%. Despite challenging economic conditions, we continue to take advantage of the omni-channel market opportunity, which is allowing us to drive higher software-related revenues.
The free cash flow guidance of $425 million to $475 million is a very good result for us and reflects a non-GAAP net income conversion rate of approximately 95%. On slide 19, you will find Q1 2016 guidance.
I expect revenue will be down 2% as reported, but up 1% constant currency. This includes a negative FX impact of approximately 3 points or $45 million.
Our non-GAAP EPS is expected to be $0.30 to $0.35 for the quarter, down for the first quarter versus prior year for a number of reasons. Our pension change, higher tax rates and unfavorable foreign currency offset by the lower share count is driving roughly $0.06 of headwinds as you can see noted in the chart.
The balance of the change is due to market condition and major financial customer rollouts ramping later in the year. The encouraging news is that we have seen positive signs in the fourth quarter in all of our businesses.
Financial Services has significant backlog coming into 2016, and our higher value offerings are doing very well. The market is moving in our favor within Retail, and Hospitality has been on a very strong trajectory.
We look forward to a very successful 2015. Now, I'll turn the call back to Bill for some closing comments.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Thank you, Bob, and perfect job on free cash flow. In summary, despite the factors that went against us in 2015, NCR achieved success in most of our key metrics, and importantly drove higher than expected free cash flow.
It's clear that omni-channel is maturing and the market opportunity for NCR is very exciting. We are also fully aware of the competitive lead we've established but remain healthily paranoid about competition in the years to come.
This healthy paranoia drives us harder every day to fuel innovation that will further expand our competitive advantage. We hope that it's evident to our investors by the leadership position we are taking in introducing new omni-channel products and solutions, and 2016 will be one of NCR's biggest years ever for new product introduction.
It's important to us because every customer call I attend, regardless of market or geography TXOs (21:16) are focused on omni-channel enablement over the next several years. In addition, the solution to enable omni-channel are now becoming mainstream with market leaders making long-term buying decisions in the next 12 months to 24 months.
We talk a lot about branch transformation as one solution subset of omni-channel, but solutions with even higher potential are rapidly maturing. Unified commerce software and store transformation in Retail are both examples of large growing markets and future growth drivers in the years ahead.
These same solutions helped NCR Retail achieve solid results in Q4 and 2015. Similarly, in Hospitality omni-channel software, guest experience applications and mobile point-of-sale were drivers of success this past year, and will be more so in the years to come.
As mentioned, branch transformation continues to be an exciting growth market in Financial Services, but like other industries we are seeing enterprise omni-channel software growth becoming an important solution for the future of this market, and while we are facing stronger macro headwinds in the Financial Services space, we remain very confident in the growth potential of this segment. Finally, I want to comment on our progress in services and sales transformation, as well as the ongoing market consolidation in our industry.
First, I wanted to update you that NCR is making good progress vis-à-vis services and sales transformation. We are seeing better results across the board in terms of improved customer satisfaction and our ability to successfully transition to a more consultative solution (23:20) capability.
Both areas of focus are multi-year efforts and remain critical to our future success. As for our industry, there is finally recognition that the future is about omni-channel enablement and end-to-end solutions, not selling boxes coupled with (23:38) services.
While we continue to maintain our position as a number one provider of point-of-sale, self-checkout and ATMs, we are also transforming our company into the leading omni-channel solution provider globally, and legacy consolidation continues to occur. First with Oracle and MICROS, then with TOSHIBA TEC and IBM, and now with Diebold and Wincor.
And we strongly believe that market consolidation will only increase the opportunities for NCR. This consolidation and future strategic moves by industry participants are a clear response to the needs of our customers, and their inherent focus on omni-channel enablement.
As I said earlier, we feel like we have established a healthy, competitive advantage that we intend to build on by ramping up our innovation efforts, new product introduction, and further cloud as well as mobile growth. Now, I'll open the call up for questions.
Operator
Thank you. And our first question comes from Katy Huberty with Morgan Stanley.
Kathryn Lynn Huberty - Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC
Thank you. Good afternoon.
Typically, over the past three years or four years, the first quarter EPS has made up about 15% to 19% of the full year earnings and guidance implies a much lower mix around 12% of EPS coming in the first quarter. Can you just walk through what some of the headwinds are in first quarter that then alleviate as you move through the year?
And then I have a follow up.
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah. Katy, this is Bob, and then others can chime in.
But when I look at the operating income as a percentage of the full-year guidance, it's around 15%. The nine-year average has been 15.5%.
The last couple of years have been a little bit higher than that, you're right 16%, 17%. So it is a little bit slower than what we saw the last couple of years.
But overall, I would say, the backlog is good coming into the year. I mentioned a couple of times that we're seeing slower backlog rollout primarily in the financial industry.
So while the first quarter is a little bit less, it's not a lot, and it's really reflective of that rollout.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. Katy, this is Bill.
I would add that the primary reason really is some slower rollout of large branch projects that are coming mainly in Q2 and Q3. So it's a little bit slower, but I'm quite pleased with the ramp in the first half of the year in Q2 and then in the back half.
Kathryn Lynn Huberty - Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC
And last quarter you talked about the delayed conversion of backlog relating to a higher mix of innovative products and higher mix of software. Do you think that, that still explains the delay or is some of the weakness we've seen in the stock market and the bank stocks in particular telling us that there was maybe some constraints around budgets?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
I'll kick the call off with an answer and then Andy will give you his point of view as well on budget. But we're not seeing right now any budgetary constraints.
And in fact, I would say, for branch in particular and backlog rollout, some of this is NCR induced and that we are working hard on finalizing some of our new solutions in the market, and that is also taking some time. So we're partly to blame on new projects rollout, but generally speaking, the ramp up of the backlog is really Q2 and beyond.
Andy?
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Yeah. Katy, I mean, you're looking at a situation, it's a really good story medium to long term, quarter-to-quarter it's got the challenges that you're mentioning, and you got a backlog position in Financial Services that ends 2015, up 14% constant currency.
You've got a brand new product launch that is both in the ATM and the branch space that starts to come live in a big way in the second quarter. And then, we ramp from there.
So like Bill said, not budgetary constraints at all, we just need to drive the launches of these solutions, and then we start releasing significant backlog conversion different than we were able to in 2015.
Kathryn Lynn Huberty - Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC
Okay. Thank you.
That's helpful color.
Operator
And next will be Dan Perlin with RBC Capital Markets.
Daniel R. Perlin - RBC Capital Markets LLC
Thanks. My question is, can you just give us an update on now the Blackstone transaction is behind you guys, and I'm just wondering how those conversations are going in terms of what they are helping you with bringing to the table, incremental cost synergies that they envision, maybe that's not fully embedded yet, might be conservative guidance, I don't know.
I'm just wondering if you could bring us forward a little bit on those discussions. Thanks.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. Dan, we're off to a good start with Blackstone.
We are working with their internal operations team on a number of initiatives, mainly around improving our cost structure. And Bob will give you some examples in a moment of some short-term wins.
But we're working with them very tightly, taking advantage of their $100 billion in procurement spend to reduce their overall direct cost. We're working with their teams on looking at areas like BPI through business process improvement, and also enterprise quality.
But I'd say that, generally speaking, we're looking to recoup the annual cost of that relationship through the efforts that were now underway with them. Well, Bob anything other?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah. I'd agree.
I'd say it's widespread across the company, their portfolio businesses have the $100 billion of purchasing power. So it's everything from lower prices that – at Hilton to taking advantage of some of their sourcing processes, their purchasing tools, as an example.
And so really every function at NCR is getting with the Blackstone counterpart and looking at ways so they can optimize their spend. I'd also add that what we're seeing is the access to the talent pool that exists within Blackstone.
So if we're looking for a business process improvement person or some other skill around any of our transformation areas, whether it'd be software services or sales transformation, there does seem to be a team of there that can help us with those initiatives. So I've been pleased around with the purchasing and cost, but also the talent management.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, final comment, Dan. Having Chinh Chu and Greg Blank on our board has also been a real value added for us.
You mentioned guidance, and my only other comment there would be that, I think our guidance is appropriately conservative and prudent in light of the world around us today, but we feel very confident in the achievement of our current guidance.
Daniel R. Perlin - RBC Capital Markets LLC
In that same vein are some of these cost initiatives and access to talent pools to procurement. Are those all contemplated in these estimated numbers, or is that something that's going to play out over the course of 2016 and then we might see incremental benefits actually in the latter years?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
I think that, that will play out, Dan, over the course of 2016. There could be benefit in 2016.
Bob and I will cover more of that at the upcoming Analyst Day in March. But no doubt that we do not have contemplated in the current guidance any significant improvement that will come about as a result of our Blackstone initiatives.
Daniel R. Perlin - RBC Capital Markets LLC
Okay. And then one last, if I could ask, Andy.
In the Financial Services segment, I kind of want to follow up a little bit on the original questions. There is this question about demand out there, and we heard a lot of it, I wonder if you look at the size of financial institutions, larger versus small and mid-tier.
Can you just parse maybe the demand environment in the conversations you're having with those different sized financial institutions because they don't sound like their budgeting process or their demands are at all created equal at this point? Thanks.
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Yeah. It's a fair question.
When you look at the top level growth rates for 2015, it is a tale of two stories, Dan. I would not break it down by segment of customer, I would break it down more from a BRIC versus rest of world perspective.
And when you look at an overall what was a fairly level business in 2015 versus 2014, really it was a BRIC shrink who caused us 500 basis points to 600 basis points of growth. So the rest of world grew 5% plus, but the BRIC shrink drag down the growth rates in a fairly significant way to where it looks like a pretty level business in 2015.
So it's really a BRIC story. And when we look at 2016, we've really de-risked the BRIC business in terms of our outlook here.
Last year was a tough year in the BRICs. NCR is not the only company that had that issue, and we're confident in our BRIC outlook in 2016.
Daniel R. Perlin - RBC Capital Markets LLC
Okay. Thank you, guys.
Operator
And our next question comes from Kartik Mehta with Northcoast Research.
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
Good evening. Bill, maybe you could, or Andy, you could just expand on the comments you just made a little while ago.
I'm wondering as you look at 2016, at least for the Financial Self-Service business by geography, what kind of growth you're expecting? It sounds like, Andy, your expectations for 2016 growth in the BRIC countries is pretty low.
But I wanted to get your perspective on just growth by geography in that business?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Hey, Kartik, it's Bill. I think we'll give you a little bit of color on in terms of growth in the sense of how mortgage (35:54) might move in the year.
But Andy, could you give him a little more color than that on geographic growth?
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Sure. Just in terms of the way we're looking at 2016 from a Financial Services perspective, where we're really looking at right now is a business that – you're looking at low single-digits on a global basis for Financial Services in terms of growth, and that's with about a 300 basis-point headwind from the BRICs.
So we expect the BRICs will shrink again low double-digits offset by about 5% to 6% growth in the rest of the world. That really covers the Financial Services business.
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
And then, Bill, I think you mentioned that you're seeing some good growth or growth at least in the community FIs, and I'm assuming you meant the U.S. I'm wondering what's driving, is it hardware or software.
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Bill, you want me to take that?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Go ahead, Andy, take it.
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Yeah. So it's actually a great story.
Let me start with how we closed Q4, which was order growth in the community financial institution segment of high 20%, almost 30% on order growth. So the key to the success is really not any one of the point solutions.
It's really the omni-channel story taking off. So if you look at a customer that's looking for a stable partner, who can seamlessly integrate physical and digital channels and then take out costs in terms of leveraging their legacy systems, there is really only one choice for customers.
So it's the omni-channel story that we're the only game in town for them. And then comes with that it's a hardware, software cloud bundle that is the name of the game for the community financial institution segment.
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
So Andy, are you saying it's both hardware and software, or is – because of the omni-channel it's a greater amount of software?
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Well, I wouldn't say greater one way or the other, what I would say is that it's a software driven sale then we attach hardware on to. The old NCR was certainly hardware driven sale in today, and really for all of our industry teams today, it's a software driven sale, and especially through in the community financial institution segment where they don't have the time to best agree the decision process.
They are looking for a fully integrated solution including cloud and digital banking tied in with the integration to self-service and branch transformation channel it will by the way has hardware that attaches with that to bring it to life.
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
And I guess, just one last question. I want to understand free cash flow, Bob.
Your 2016 guidance, is there a difference between the guidance you gave from a GAAP standpoint versus non-GAAP in terms of the free cash flow you will generate?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
You mean from the free cash flow guidance of $425 million to $475 million, Kartik, was your specific question?
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
Yeah. The $425 million to $475 million, if I compare that to GAAP in 2016, will it be the same or if there is a difference, what are the differences?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah. I mean, again the free cash flow number starts with a GAAP number of operating cash flow.
And then you back out CapEx and discontinued ops. So no change from 2015, and it certainly – I think people view it as a non-GAAP term free cash flow, but it's very GAAP in terms of starting with operating cash flow and just backing out CapEx and disc ops.
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
Well, perfect, Bob. So it sounds like a real solid number for 2016 then.
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah. I think from my perspective, if you look at kind of the history of free cash flow, we were in the 20% to 30% five years ago.
We had a lot of legacy issues, pension contributions, environmental, and as we've worked our way through that and driven the software business, we have 85% conversion in 2015, 95% forecast in 2016, and we've made our numbers three years in a row. Last year I gave guidance of $325 million to $375 million, and we landed at $409 million.
So that was a good answer. The whole company is energized around free cash flow, this year I've given guidance of $425 million to $475 million.
Kartik Mehta - Northcoast Research Partners LLC
Perfect. Thank you.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Thanks Kartik.
Operator
And the next question will come from Matt Summerville with Alembic Global Advisors.
Matt J. Summerville - Alembic Global Advisors LLC
Hey, thanks. Just couple questions.
First Bob, can you talk about what your goal would be in terms of a net debt to EBITDA ratio heading out of 2016? I know you exited 2015 at 2.8 times, and then I have a follow up, please.
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah. I'll share a lot more of that as part of Analyst Day and capital allocation strategy.
I will say this though, our goal remains to be solid double D. So that has not changed.
Matt J. Summerville - Alembic Global Advisors LLC
And then just as a follow up, Bill, you mentioned some things you guys are trying to do on the sales and service side of the company. Can you sort of talk about metrics that you are looking at that we can focus on, how much have your close rates improved across your sales organization, how much have your capture rates improved across your service organization, and I guess, how much more room to go is there before you would feel that you've hit your target?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. Many of the metrics we use to track sales effectiveness and transformation, you would not see, Matt.
But the best proxy for that in my view is software growth. Ultimately, our sales organization today is transitioning from, I would say, a great product, hardware orientation to a software solutions orientation, and we are in the fifth inning of that game.
And while we made good progress last year, we still have one year to two years left to complete that journey. And I would tell you today that, if you track our software growth, it's a really good proxy for sales force effectiveness because ultimately the transition believes (43:54) around solution selling and leading the software.
Matt J. Summerville - Alembic Global Advisors LLC
Thank you.
Operator
And our next question comes from Meghna Ladha with Susquehanna.
Meghna Ladha - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP
Hi. Good evening.
Thanks for taking my question. In the Financial Services segment, you indicated that you're seeing positive trends in key businesses with orders up 30% in community bank, overall backlog up.
I guess the question really is, is this related to just market share gains or market growth in general?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Andy, why don't you take that?
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Sure. Yeah.
When we look at the markets out there right now, and obviously the competitive landscapes are changing quite a bit, in the markets that we call addressable markets, in other words, where we've got sales coverage and we've got products fit, we're gaining share, no question. And then in terms of the overall market, there are certainly some areas that are growing faster than others.
But generally speaking, where we have addressable market, meaning we're focused on, from a sales perspective, and we have products that will grow in share.
Meghna Ladha - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP
Got it. And then, Bob, in the past you've provided outlook for each segment.
Can you give us some color for 2016?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
We will provide a lot more color on the business as part of Analyst Day. Right now, it was important for us to establish guidance around total revenue, around EPS, earnings and free cash flow.
We'll provide more detail as part of Analyst Day.
Meghna Ladha - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP
Okay. So then, would you be providing more details around the margins as well because I'm just trying to figure out as well, how should we think about margins in each of the segment, and which segment should we see the most margin expansion in 2016.
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah, I think, as we put together – start putting together the Analyst Day deck, I think, you will find it quite insightful in terms of the analysis that we provide. So as we move into more of the omni-channel space, we'll be talking about the business consistent with that.
Meghna Ladha - Susquehanna Financial Group LLLP
Got it. Thank you.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Thanks, Meghna.
Operator
And next will be Gil Luria with Wedbush Securities.
Gil B. Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Yes. Thanks for taking my question.
I had a couple of just financial clarifications. First of all, what's your underfunded status for the pension and obligations as of the end of the year?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Let me get that answer to you as part of this call, but maybe go to your next question, Gil, and then I'll give you an update on that.
Gil B. Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Sure, the $20 million reserve reversal, could you give us a little bit more detail into what that entails, what was the situation there?
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Yeah, I can. So this was in our Emerging Industries, it relates to an airport construction project in the Middle East.
In this situation, the prime contractor got dismissed and we were a sub-contractor. We've been a very valued partner of the government and continue to be.
This has been a long-term project for us. It was revenue that was booked years ago at relatively low margins in terms of it being an airport rollout, and this change of the prime contractor has caused a challenge in terms of ultimate payment.
So we took a reserve, we continue to work that. It was necessary to book a reserve at the end of Q4, but we continue to work through payment options even though they might take some time.
Gil B. Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Got it. So then the only other one I have is, branch transformation.
The growth rate decelerated in the fourth quarter. How much total dollars did you do branch transformation last year, and what's your expectation for this year?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. I think total a year ago FX-neutral was somewhere in the $205 million range against our target of $230 million.
We probably caused about $15 million to $20 million of the growth challenge in that project readiness was an issue for us in the back half of the year that we'll solve here in the first half of 2016. So demand was certainly there for our solution, but we missed the mark.
And Andy, why don't you give additional color on that and some color on 2016?
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Yeah. It's a business that we're looking at and you're talking about a 50% type of growth business.
We think it will continue into 2016. The real drivers for us in 2016 continue to be the same things, but in broader geographies.
So you got customers out there trying to change the game in terms of expanded store hours, expanded the distribution points, less labor to handle the service models that they are putting in place. The community financial institution market in the United States has been the main driver for us.
The majors are a big driver for us in 2016, expanding more broadly in Middle East, Africa in 2016 as they need to change their economic models of how they run branches in the retail network. And then finally, Western Europe we see steam picking up greatly there as well.
That's what the funnel tells us.
Gil B. Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Got it. Thank you.
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
Hey Gil, on your pension question.
Gil B. Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Yes.
Robert P. Fishman - SVP, Chief Financial & Accounting Officer
So it's very consistent with what we had signaled back in Q2. You remember we transferred the overfunded London plan.
So with that left was around $580 million of underfunded, think of that primarily as U.S. and Germany.
Germany is a pay as you go plan. So that's very close to what you'll see in the 10-K.
Gil B. Luria - Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Got it. Thank you very much.
Operator
Next will be Ian Zaffino with Oppenheimer.
Richard Faulkner - Oppenheimer & Co., Inc. (Broker)
Hey guys. This is actually Rick Faulkner for Ian.
Just wondering if you've seen any change in the pricing environment in Financial given the consolidation between Wincor and Diebold?
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, we have seen for the latter part of 2015, and concurrently 2016 consistent pressure on pricing because both of those companies are coming together and wanting to perform well prior to integration. But we do expect post integration for that hopefully to improve going forward.
Andy, you may add some additional color.
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Yeah. Rick, I mean, it's a marriage that's not yet happened, and we're in an engagement period now.
And like any marriage, that spending, a lots of things get said now, and what ends up happening we don't know. What typically happens is you'll see stabilization occur in terms of two companies that become one, have to drive a tremendous amount of rationalization when it comes to product lines and costs.
And so we're looking forward to that occurring, and we think once that happens that what our customers are telling us is, they're really looking for stable partners, they're really for clarity of roadmaps. How that make – when we're coming out with new products in that same period of time, our hope is that can be favorable to margins.
And between now and then, it's a certainly highly competitive, as it always is, in these markets, in the ATM space, less competitive in the branch transformation and software space where we have a competitive edge and clear differentiation.
Richard Faulkner - Oppenheimer & Co., Inc. (Broker)
Okay. Yeah, I mean, I guess, I was expecting that maybe the pricing environment could become more favorable, but it sounds like you're saying, it's all too early to tell.
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
I would say that if things do become more favorable, typically in situations like this, what you'll see is that, that would happen after the marriage was consummated, which of course is not the case just yet.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. And Rick, through all of that, as you can see, we did improve operating margins, both in Q4 and on the full year in financials through all of the challenges we faced, plus a pricing environment that was a bit more aggressive than usual.
Richard Faulkner - Oppenheimer & Co., Inc. (Broker)
Okay. Great.
Thanks.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Thanks.
Operator
And your next question comes from Matt Summerville with Alembic Global Advisors.
Matt J. Summerville - Alembic Global Advisors LLC
Hey, thanks. I just had a quick follow up.
First on China, your two largest competitors have announced some sort of pursuing of a joint venture type strategy in order to be able to better participate in that market. We all know about the, by local requirement scene that's going on there.
So if you could talk about how you're thinking about China, how you're positioned in or around that. And then secondarily, with Brazil, I believe towards the second half of this year your contract expires with Bradesco, sort of what the thought is there, what kind of happens going forward in your view?
Thank you.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
On China, Matt, we are looking at multiple options of how to successfully participate in that market having lived and worked there myself, I have a unique insight in how to do that. And I won't comment on our competition and what they've done, but we will address that this year, and the way we'll address it, I think, will be most beneficial to our shareholders and our long-term aspirations in China.
On Brazil, Andy why don't you take that one?
Andrew S. Heyman - SVP, President, NCR Financial Services
Yes. I think the partnership we have in Brazil, as we look long-term we've now built a nine figure business in Brazil from a much smaller base five years ago.
So as we look at the next five years, we're continuing to expand in Brazil with a more software driven approach. How we do that will depend on a few different variables.
Going about it now alone, not to discuss, the whole thing can be removed from the current joint venture that we have. We're very confident and independent thriving Brazil business, notwithstanding the market challenges there given the economy.
So that right now would be – I'd say, our most likely scenario as think medium-term to long-term in Brazil, but we've got of options and we'll explore all of them.
Matt J. Summerville - Alembic Global Advisors LLC
Thanks, guys.
Operator
Go ahead.
William R. Nuti - Chairman, President & Chief Executive Officer
Thank you all for joining and see you on March 7, and I look forward to see you there. Good night.
Operator
Thank you. And that does conclude today's conference call.
We do thank you for your participation today.